When my last novel On Behalf of the Family was published, my head felt emptied. I had nothing left to say. Perhaps some of you know that feeling. A new plot wasn’t waiting in the wings. I didn’t have a file folder of ideas percolating. My characters weren’t demanding to take the stage once again. And for sure, I knew the world wasn’t breathless with anticipation for the next Detective Dave Mason mystery.
I just started writing for pleasure: I. Writing Your First Mystery; II. Plotting Your First Mystery; and, III. Creating Killer Characters.
Short eBooks of about ten thousand words.
The writing was a joy because it flowed so easily. None of that head-scratching anxiety of write three sentences, delete two. I discovered how much I’d learned in the process of writing four unpublishable novels, then four fairly successful whodunits.
In that long process I had taught myself how to write, how to plot, and how to motivate memorable characters on the printed page. The ebooks on mystery writing were meant to share what I’d learned. I was writing for someone out there with a burning idea who didn’t know where to start. Or had begun and hit a wall.
I didn’t do any of the sensible things I should have done, for example, research the market on writing craft books, think about marketing strategies—any of that. I learned when the books were finished that there are many books on the craft of writing mysteries.
Some of them are thoughtful and good guides into the basics. For example, the detective and the killer are introduced quickly to play fair with the reader. The killer may look like a good guy and the reader’s attention misdirected in a welter of details. Have you noticed there are usually three red herrings?
I’m a great believer in writing character sketches, that is, writing a detailed backstory for each of the major characters. The detective and the killer must be equally strong and interesting to carry the reader’s attention for roughly 300 pages. To suggest ways you can bring your major characters to life I gave 20 questions as a prompt.
I wrote about naming characters, and choosing a setting and a time period. I suggested how to kick yourself in the pants when the plot stalls, and how to craft the thrilling chase scene at the climax when the detective brings down the killer.
Writing Your First Mystery is available as a free download on my website. The others are cheap enough to take a chance on.
My voice may not ignite the spark to write your first mystery. If this is not the book for you, try another craft book. Study the first 50 pages of mysteries that you love. Figure out why you like them.
The barriers to publishing your own first mystery have broken down. There is an insatiable appetite for crime fiction. If you are a reader who has even a vague idea of writing a mystery, I urge you to begin. No one else will ever have the same life experience and voice as you do. You are the only one who can tell your story. And your story is important.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Mar Preston is the author of four police procedurals set in the Santa Monica Police Department against the backdrop of a glitzy beach city bristling with celebrity, international, and homeless crime. A second series takes place in a tranquil California mountain village. Preston is a co-founder of the local SPCA, a dog park, a network of low-power radio stations, and picks up road kill for her wildlife rehab buddies to feed the big raptors. She would like to tell you that she has a fixed writing schedule that she adheres to rigidly, but this is not true.
You can learn more about Mar and her work at her website. She can also be found on Facebook and Goodreads.
michael kors uk says
I used to be able to find good advice from your blog posts.
My web blog … michael kors uk
Dani greer says
I just bought all three. Will now try to connect on FB and Twitter. Nice to meet you!
Mar Preston says
Hello yourself there, Dani Greer
I don’t think I’m very hard to find. Where are you at in the process of writing mysteries?
April Moore says
Really great post! And it couldn’t have come at a better time, as I’m making my first attempt at writing a mystery. Thanks for offering your book for free–I just downloaded it!
Mar Preston says
I’d love to know what you think, whether I hit the high points, whether there were sections that seemed skimpy.
Good luck with your first.
Elspeth Futcher says
These are terrific guidelines for first-time mystery writers. I’ve been writing mysteries in various formats (for the last 10 years in a game format) and my best hint would be to start with your victim and then ask ‘why’. Once you know that, everything else will begin to fall into place.
Mar Preston says
Yes, once you know the victim there’s somebody sneaking up on him. There has to be a reason the killer wants him dead. Then the murder method and the alibis and the thrilling chase scene comes together.
Oh, it all sounds so easy, doesn’t it? I’m 175 pages into my current book and it is NOT going well. Wish me luck.
Alex J. Cavanaugh says
Even if there are other books that are similar, yours are still unique because you have a different perspective,
Mar Preston says
So true, Alex. Mine are set in Santa Monica, which is slightly off the LA beaten track. But small town, big city, there’s an insatiable appetite for crime fiction entertainment. Think. If you were e pharmacist you could think up novel murder methods. Settings like a Unitarian church, or a filling station in Death Valley, or a border crossing in a snowstorm in Montana. And if you love local history, the time period doesn’t have to be next Wednesday.
Is this why we love mysteries? Their ability to set us down on streets that we know we’ll never walk?
Margot Kinberg says
Pat – Thanksf or hosting Mar.
Mar – Thanks for sharing your experiences. It’s very helpful to writers who working on their first novels to get input from writers who’ve gone through the process. I wish you much success.
Mar Preston says
Gone thru the process nine times now constructing a story and coming up with memorable characters. My first four novels were literary fiction because I was in an MFA program. So much for that. I thought mysteries would be easier. Ha!
Patricia says
LOL. That’s what I thought, too, Mar, which is why I started with mysteries. I learned very fast how complicated the plots and characters can be.